| Episode | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Immunity/Reward | Red | Red | Orange | Orange | Orange | Orange | Orange | Derpy | Hotrod | Hotrod | Derpy | Derpy | ||
| Eliminated | N/A | JT | N/A | Jacal | Alto | N/A | Gamer | Blizzard | N/A | DJ | Hotrod | Bobby Toast | ||
| Placement | N/A | 10th Place | N/A | 9th Place | 8th Place | N/A | 7th Place | 6th Place | N/A | 5th Place | 4th Place | Runners-Up | ||
| Derpy | Lost | Safe | Reward | Immune | Reward | Reward | Immune | Immune | Lost | Safe | Immune | Winner | ||
| Toast | Lost | Safe | Reward | Immune | Reward | Reward | Immune | Low | Lost | Safe | Safe | 1st Runner-Up | ||
| Bobby | Reward | Immune | Lost | Safe | Lost | Lost | Safe | Safe | Lost | Low | Low | 2nd Runner-Up | ||
| Hotrod | Lost | Safe | Reward | Immune | Reward | Reward | Immune | Safe | Reward | Immune | Out | Voted Out | ||
| DJ | Reward | Immune | Lost | Safe | Lost | Lost | Safe | Safe | Lost | Out | Voted Out | |||
| Blizzard | Reward | Immune | Lost | Low | Lost | Lost | Low | Out | Voted Out | |||||
| Gamer | Reward | Immune | Lost | Safe | Lost | Lost | Out | Voted Out | ||||||
| Alto | Lost | Low | Reward | Immune | Quit | Quit | ||||||||
| Jacal | Reward | Immune | Lost | Out | Voted Out | |||||||||
| JT | Lost | Out | Voted Out | |||||||||||
| Notes | • Bold Safe = Received first marshmallow • Low = Last to receive a marshmallow • Out = The person was eliminated | |||||||||||||